Tony D'Antonio

11/25/2024, 9:10:23 PM

On Sundays, it's Happy Hour all day. Bites, drinks, and service were excellent! 👌

LAUREN VAZQUEZ

4/27/2025, 5:26:46 PM

Decided to try Sundays Well instead of our usual 3rd Ave spots. The patio was open, and although only the brunch menu was available (no regular lunch options), we decided to give it a shot. The Palomas were excellent — easily the highlight. Unfortunately, service and food quality fell short. After accidentally knocking over a drink, we realized we had no utensils or napkins and struggled to get our server’s attention as she focused mainly on a larger party. I eventually had to go inside to ask for help. The waitress brought a rag but set it down, and walked away without offering to assist in cleaning up. When the food arrived (thanks to a very helpful runner), the burger ordered medium was well-done, and the Shakshuka eggs were severely undercooked. Our server was understanding and took the Shakshuka off the bill, and even discounted the burger despite us agreeing to just share that instead but overall the experience was disappointing. I understand staff can sometimes be stretched thin, but given how many great spots are nearby, we’ll likely stick to more reliable options in the future.

Giang Nguyen

2/11/2024, 12:06:45 AM

Had the paper plane cocktail and the crispy fish tacos. Pretty standard, but I have a bias for fish tacos, so standard fish tacos are 4 ⭐ by default in my book. Minor knock is that the slaw, mayo, and relish together were a little strong and kind of overwhelmed the fish. Why is it so dark? I get it, but I also don't get it 🤣 low light has its merits, but this was super dark 😄 (the camera make the photos/videos look brighter than the lighting in reality)

Nadia Gonzales-Prada

3/21/2025, 2:35:00 PM

Incredible experience! I worked with Greg and Rob to throw a surprise party and they went above and beyond to ensure my party and I had a good time. 10/10 for hospitality, customer service, and vibes. Will definitely come back and recommend to friends. Thanks to everyone here for making that night so special!

Olivia N

1/1/2025, 11:48:14 PM

Overall rating: 4.1 I went here for a social event in the bar area in the back. I was very early and I didn’t know where I was going. The place was very packed (after work hours) but when I went.. I had a weird experience. The hostess was very nice and told me to walk towards the back. But when I got lost and wasn’t sure if I was going the right way. I just felt like I was being stared at. I don’t know how to describe it, but as a POC - it was very eerie. At first I thought the staring was just you know, another customer. But then I found out later on that it was the manager that was staring and he didn’t offer to help someone who clearly looked lost. He looked at me like I didn’t belong. I ended up just getting one drink and called it. The place just isn’t for me.

Nicole Sparacio

5/9/2024, 12:38:33 AM

Such a lovely spot & hidden gem! Fantastic happy hour. Backyard patio is very pleasant & loved the bulb lights. Only got the fries but they were SO GOOD!

Ellen

8/26/2023, 1:35:19 AM

Nice bar with a spacious patio in the back. Went there for happy hour with work colleagues. French fries were ok as well as the fried cauliflower. The B-side cocktail had an odd aftertaste which I would not recommend.

Alan Varghese

9/14/2022, 3:43:26 AM

All of Sunday is Happy hour. Nice ambience with ample indoor and outdoor seating, great food, music that isn't too loud allowing you to hear one another, and according to my friends good cocktails. The fish tacos and their fries with the in- house sauce were really good. The wine and cocktail collection has about 8-10 options each (mostly $12-$14). Draft also has 10 options ($5-$8). Food prices are decent for the amount of food you get.

Nicole S

5/9/2024, 12:38:33 AM

Such a lovely spot & hidden gem! Fantastic happy hour. Backyard patio is very pleasant & loved the bulb lights. Only got the fries but they were SO GOOD!

Renan

2/14/2025, 4:18:20 AM

My first time here and I will definitely be back. Delicious food (the spinach and artichoke appetizer was our favorite). The drinks were tasty and all reasonably priced. The bartender Gustavo was very helpful and friendly. He made our experience so much better. Thank you so much!

Evan Burrell

3/17/2025, 12:53:13 AM

We hosted our engagement party at Sunday's Well, and it was absolutely seamless from start to finish! The atmosphere was warm and inviting, the staff was incredibly attentive, and the service was top-notch. Everything—from the food and drinks to the overall vibe—was perfect, making it an unforgettable night for us and our guests. The team made the entire planning process stress-free, and they truly went above and beyond to ensure everything ran smoothly. We would 100% host an event here again and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a fantastic spot in NYC. Thank you, Sunday's Well, for making our special night even more special!

Lauren Denysek

7/28/2024, 5:09:14 PM

Stopped in here for Happy Hour in their hidden backyard. Atmosphere was fun, weather was beautiful, and drinks were great. A definite must stop for an affordable hangout!

Alice Litchfield

5/8/2025, 2:22:20 AM

We had a private event here and it was great! The team were great with communication, and they had the space set up really nicely for us. Great drinks, great food and very reasonable prices!